"... I don't use it as lip liner. I bought the simply spice color, and I use that as a eyeliner, and it works great. Did it by accident one day, and ended up liking the results lol"

    "I have used this lip liner for several years and love it! It goes on smooth, it lasts, and is just the right shade for me at 60 years of age. I always buy several when it is on sale as I used it everyday."

    "This is a good lip liner because most of the colors are nice and will match up with a great variety of lipsticks. The price is affordable, too. Not having to sharpen them is a good plus. The big problem is the staying power.

I feel that this lip liner just isn't designed to last. A good lipliner will stay on all day, even if you have to re-apply your lipstick. I just found that these didn't do the trick. Revlon's Colorstay lipliner and Clinique both have lipliners that will last and last. You might as well invest in something that will last all day.

Conclusion: Nice color selection, but I think you would do better investing in a longer-wearing product. "