"Clinique's Sheer Shaper for Lips does the job of keeping my lipstick from feathering, but it is just too sheer for me. The description says sheer and it definitely means sheer...it's so sheer that I can barely tell that I've used it at all. I prefer a lip liner that I can see at least a little bit. If you want sheer though, this is the right pencil to go for.
"

    "This is one of the BEST lip liners I've ever used. It's creamy and sheer, but it really helps your lipstick stay. I love a natural, "no make-up" look, and this is a great product for it. Blushy is my favorite color- matches the natural color of my lips perfectly. Not sure if the color was discontinued, though- hope not!
"

    "I bought Clinique Sheer Shaper for Lips-Lip Liner
in hint of pink. The color is beautiful and subtle- just a couple shades darker than my natural lip color. It is a decent liner for everyday lip definition. The only problem is that it doesn't transfer to lips easily, especially moisturized lips. The product is true to description- very sheer.
"