"I purchased Secret because I have been looking for this particular shade in a lip liner. it goes on creamy-smooth, then sets beautifully. however, for the cost, the pencil does not last long. [the color lasts on the lips, but the product itself runs out too soon.] and once the little cylindrical insert of color gets low, it likes to attempt to leap out of its housing. this seems to be the nature of many mechanical lip pencils. the formula IS superior, but I'll search for this shade in a non-mechanical lip pencil form.
"

    "Hourglass's Trace Lip Liner is everything I want in a lip pencil. For one, I love the fact that you don't have to sharpen it, which means no product waste and no time wasted sharpening. It glides on soft as melted butter and is easy to blend with the little brush on the other end, which is another convenient feature of this pencil. The color is long wearing. Seriously I put this on in the morning and I don't have to reapply at all. This is an utterly fantastic lip liner and worth every penny!
"